Come on garfa, did tou even read the post i clearly stated that:
The best way to pick a set of speakers is to head out to your nearest speialist car audio dealer, and audition the speakers on display. Dont ay so much atention to how they look or who they are made by (I will address this later) just listen to the music and compare the sets you test. It will soon be clear how different one set of speakers can sound entirely different to another set.
The list is a GUIDE nothing else. I wrote this only to help people out. I have stated that brand is not important and to listen to the speakers, so i dont understand what you are critisising???