i used a butane soldering iron, but changed to head to a blowtorch head that came with it, i couldn't get them red, only a bright orange, the part the flame was focused on went brighter, so i tried to rotate it so it'd all heat evenly.
when they cooled in the water they dropped all these black flakes in it (maybe carbon from the flame), and afterwards the washers had dark spots.
is this what they're meant to come out like?