component vs 3/4 way splits

[love the general]

ok i know this is a noob question and i didn't get any clear answers fro the search function but i wanna know which is better for a set of front splits a set of component speakers or a set of 2/3/4 way of coaxials. for arguments sake say they are the same brand, same size, same wattage etc. thanks

 

[arrow224]

Splits. No doubt about it. You can position the tweeter differently to the other drivers, and so can create a better sound stage and sound depth.

However coaxials are good because all the sound originates from the one point. This is an ideal situation - all sound coming from one point. However, in order to get it sounding good, a pretty funky mounting position is needed, quite unpractical for cars.

 

[holdenboy]

Splits and components are essentially the same. These are the best choice, provided they are installed properly.

 

[Fun_Bucket]

As above, i definately go with the splits, just think a coaxial speaker has to do 2 things at the same time. A splits sytstem, does just that, it splits the duties up, allowing each component to concentrate and doing just one thing. You'll have the added advantage of choosing the tweeter placement, and will allow for better tuning overall compared to if you were to install coaxials..

 

[StoneX]

As above, i definately go with the splits, just think a coaxial speaker has to do 2 things at the same time. A splits sytstem, does just that, it splits the duties up, allowing each component to concentrate and doing just one thing. You'll have the added advantage of choosing the tweeter placement, and will allow for better tuning overall compared to if you were to install coaxials..

Good coaxials have proper high and low pass filters like splits, so the woofer and tweeter are doing their own thing.

arrow was on the money regarding the mounting position.