Chuck on the used pump and send the other back to get your money back and they can see the mode of failure. Weeping from the hole means the seal has failed. Water pumps use a ceramic seal which don't like particle contamination so definitely filter the used coolant when re-filling. You can also get something like this
http://www.derek.com.au/tefbafilter.html
Our VX has done 230,000km and is still on it's original pump, I do have a spare on the shelf so no doubt it will last until a mate or somebody else borrows my new/spare...