Welcome to Just Commodores, a site specifically designed for all people who share the same passion as yourself.

New Posts Contact us

Just Commodores Forum Community

It takes just a moment to join our fantastic community

Register

2004 vz misfiring

krusing

Well-Known Member, Possibly for the wrong reasons
Joined
Jun 21, 2014
Messages
5,406
Reaction score
4,040
Points
113
Location
Melbourne, Bayside
Members Ride
2002 VY L67 Calais Sedan, 2012 VE L77 Calais Wagon
As mentioned above,
Get a professional scan tool on to it,
And run some tests from the analyser (scan tool)
It could be 2 faults that appear to be one,
So you could be chasing your tail.

But It does sound like a common denominator causing the fault.
 
Last edited:

bcw61

Member
Joined
Sep 14, 2009
Messages
357
Reaction score
18
Points
18
Location
Northern suburbs of Adelaide
Members Ride
VZ 2005 Executive Wagon
I saw a case of an injector not firing because of damage to a reluctor wheel. No injector signal. Wasn’t the ECM. Was a missing tooth on the reluctor wheel. So it was found after many other workshops threw parts at it. Lots of dollars. One guy did a proper look and found the cause of a lack of signal to the injector was caused by the missing tooth giving wrong data to the ECM and confusing TDC data.

I would agree with your explanation EXCEPT: the OP has indicated that at one stage, the problem appeared to have disappeared for a while, then re-appeared. If your theory was correct, then I would expect the fault should show up consistently and continuously (a missing/damaged reluctor tooth isn't exactly going to re-grow/repair itself in a hurry ;)). The fact that the fault seems intermittent, seems to indicate an intermittent wiring issue or an ECU fault.

Actually, looking at the OPs reported symptoms, it appears it may be thermally related (ie, only appearing after the engine has run for a while and warmed up), which might further indicate an ECU issue.
 

AC Delco-reunited

New Member
Joined
Jan 29, 2023
Messages
2
Reaction score
4
Points
3
Age
69
Location
Perth
Members Ride
2004 VY Commodore executive 3.8 sedan
Hey guys need some gurus help, been trying to diagnose my car myself to save some dollars..

So my 2004 vz alloytec randomly started to run like crap after driving along the highway, after coming to a stop at home it was idiling pretty rough, I checked the car the next morning and started Fine etc, after driving it for about 10-15 minutes it began to misfire again… I then began my diagnostic side of things by checking coil packs… I came across bank 3 coil pack being faulty and not working… I then replaced it with a new coilpack… car started and drove fine about about another 10-15 minutes and the misfiring came back but was intermittent misfires wasn’t consistent… then eventually it came back as before and became consistent … I then Began to check coils again and some how it was the exact same one… I then changed spark plugs and gapped them to 0.7 as recommended by my mechanic and switched coilpacks over with a different one… then after the misfiring has just become consistent from start up and still from bank 3 the coil unplugged is making no difference… I then began to dig deeper and changed the injector around to see if it switched which coil it would misfire from and still hasn’t made any difference…. I’m lost in what I have to do right now…. Car was running absolute perfect till now… please help
Hi mate. I had same issue until it finally died on me. Before it rolled to the curb for what could have been its last time I have had at that point had a platoon of Mobile mechanics from the same company mauling the car. It went on for over 3 months.. All of them did the same thing systematic elimination and using their expensive test module computer gadget. He changed DFI module. Worked, I paid him and it stalled in the city at the traffic lights that same day. Tow truck $100.

New guy same company replaced Crank angle drove it. It started I paid him. I drove it a tidy 7 klm and it stalled on a roundabout. Dirty looks from everyone. Tow truck back to home.$120

Called same company different guy came out, Changed Cam sensor started paid him drove it about 1 klm stalled wouldn't start. Tow truck $100. Phoned company, not one but two Mobile mechanic graced my driveway from the, same company... One changed out the new DFI module again and applied more grease to it. The other checked the fuel and manned the meter for faults couldn't understand what they were saying because it wasn't English. Said DFI was faulty because it had heated up. Showed me scorched metal plate. He replaced it didn't charge me for new one but charged me labour. (he said it was under warranty ????) Total Costs at this juncture was over $1600 These two were the 4th visitors and it looked promising as it ran sweet as a nut on the drive. I slept easy that night.

Car failed next morning. Crank but no start. I called the same company. Had to get taxis to and from my appointment in the city. The car sat on the drive for 6 days as the mobile company owner said 'it was a holiday and I would have to book on line'. Grrrr.

The newest caped crusader came out after 4 days waiting. The mechanics seamed to be getting younger each time. He followed the same routine as I watched eagerly this pre choreographed explanation of what he was checking. Same as the other guys but the diagnosis took a turn for the worst now as its ailment progressed to another part of the cars anatomy. He showed me the fault readings that had now populated the screen and after stating that errors were ABS, cam sensor, ignition mass air intake. He said more than likely the BCU under the dash. Then went onto say the car would have to go to THEIR workshop and do I have RAC call out? It was at this point I suddenly realised they were not getting younger I was getting older and the car was back to its original position, a non Fn starter.

I told him at that point that mobile means he comes out and fixes the car. I then said to him. 'just leave'. Sent him packing. Lost my sht and told him to tell his boss that its a scam keep replacing a part each time and charging me labour every time.

Anyway, I got onto THIS site and I saw the same issue over and over again all on the older models all related to coil pack BCU sensors ect etc . So I did a quick look over the Wiring block connection to DFI . II saw on this website (see pics below) and got out my cheap and nasty multi meter. I turned ignition on and tested the green wire female connection in the block. 'Hello' I said . 'No reading'. I sprayed some electrical cleaner down the end of the sucker and used a fine piece of wire on the female metal block careful not to damage it. Pushed the parting bits back to a square shape There was plenty of crap on and in it. I pushed the little blade that holds the male part in place on the small metal square back into its position very carefully and put it back onto module.

Well f*&^% me, it started first time, rev counter static not fluctuating and hasn't stalled once for over 2 months.

My advice is check the 12 volt feed wire FIRST (Usually green wire nearest). Judging from info on here cars start and then stall under load or decelerating at lights etc. This design is crap and that 12 volt feed is the one that heats up. Apparently that wire in the block provides activation for DFI ignition system to BCU and sensors and is obviously prone to bad connection that sends out intermittent voltage drops to BCU. It arcs and causes it to heat up spread more and fail. Thanks to the guy that posted these pics and his own story similar to mine that set me on the straight and narrow. (Bought second hand one just in case for $20 ) AC Delco were asking telephone numbers for a new original. Like anything this little gem of info is that block requires maintenance.. it shouldn't, but it does Good clean and reseat the little connection ends to snug fit on the DFI module pins.
Hope this story helps.

PS. It may well not be the DFI wiring block so if not and you are in an emergency try this for BCU failure.

If your car doesn't start take out Starter relay turn on ignition. jump wire across relay points. If it starts remove wire immediately if it stops you will have to take key out and do it again turn key to light up dahs repeat. watch this Youtube and follow instructions to the letter.

Works in most cases as it bypasses the BCU computer if that is the issue. You can drive the car but if you stop it you will have to do process again.
 

Attachments

  • burnt pin 2.jpg
    burnt pin 2.jpg
    36.2 KB · Views: 87
  • DFI Module Connector.JPG
    DFI Module Connector.JPG
    111.2 KB · Views: 80
Last edited:

Fu Manchu

We’ll get together. Have a few laughs.
Joined
Mar 18, 2006
Messages
17,994
Reaction score
22,730
Points
113
Location
WA.
Members Ride
VZ Crewman, VZ Cross 8, & ya mum.
I would agree with your explanation EXCEPT: the OP has indicated that at one stage, the problem appeared to have disappeared for a while, then re-appeared. If your theory was correct, then I would expect the fault should show up consistently and continuously (a missing/damaged reluctor tooth isn't exactly going to re-grow/repair itself in a hurry ;)). The fact that the fault seems intermittent, seems to indicate an intermittent wiring issue or an ECU fault.

Actually, looking at the OPs reported symptoms, it appears it may be thermally related (ie, only appearing after the engine has run for a while and warmed up), which might further indicate an ECU issue.
My point simply being that before OP jumps at replacing a major part at great expense, those components should be thoroughly tested to prove the fault. Assuming it is a major repair (by the repairer) should be avoided.
 

lout

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 13, 2006
Messages
5,567
Reaction score
4,276
Points
113
Age
60
Location
Langwarrin Victoria
Members Ride
VXii Executive V6 , VYii Adventra LS1
It was at this point I suddenly realised they were not getting younger I was getting older and the car was back to its original position, a non Fn starter.
Thanks for that. coffee came out my nose, now i have to clean coffee out of the keyboard
 

Habby18796

New Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2023
Messages
5
Reaction score
4
Points
3
Age
27
Location
Sydney
Members Ride
Vz sv6 Ute
Hey guys thanks all for your responses… so come to conclusion cars all sorted got a test light tested all wirings to injector’s and coils was getting all pulses etc so ecu was obviously powering properly… plugged scanner In and tested injectors individually and all injectors weren’t at correct levels and injector 3 was completely stuffed… so replaced all injectors and car runs mint now thankfully… process of elimination now all sorted
 

Fu Manchu

We’ll get together. Have a few laughs.
Joined
Mar 18, 2006
Messages
17,994
Reaction score
22,730
Points
113
Location
WA.
Members Ride
VZ Crewman, VZ Cross 8, & ya mum.
Stumbled on this video. Watched all three. The poor guy. He was tested. GM injector circuit issues.

Solution bad earth. Caught him out. Replaced ECM. Fault occurs again.

My point always is to first check and clean the harness earths. It costs nothing in parts. It’s not complicated.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Lex
Top