Welcome to Just Commodores, a site specifically designed for all people who share the same passion as yourself.

New Posts Contact us

Just Commodores Forum Community

It takes just a moment to join our fantastic community

Register

2015 VF SV6 - Shaking intermittently at idle.

MossNZ

New Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2017
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Points
1
Age
34
Location
Auckland, NZ
Members Ride
2015 VF SV6 Commodore
Noticed the car feels like it's jerking to one side when it's sitting idle in gear (at the lights), and in park. It's not constant, but varies. The car was serviced before I took collection of it, and has done 35,560 to the clock.

I'm new to Holden's, did some searching and saw older cars doing it but threads cut short. It drives fine in every other regard.

Sorry for lack of knowledge.
 

426Cuda

SUBLIME!
Joined
Dec 15, 2013
Messages
4,181
Reaction score
3,015
Points
113
Location
Wagga Wagga
Members Ride
VF Redline Sedan - A6 Spitfire MSE...
Noticed the car feels like it's jerking to one side when it's sitting idle in gear (at the lights), and in park. It's not constant, but varies. The car was serviced before I took collection of it, and has done 35,560 to the clock.

I'm new to Holden's, did some searching and saw older cars doing it but threads cut short. It drives fine in every other regard.

Sorry for lack of knowledge.
Sounds normal. Even goven the baby standard cam. I've read Holden programs this into the tune to give a V8 idle feel. Can't confirm this but.
Mine does this too and I like it.
 

MossNZ

New Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2017
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Points
1
Age
34
Location
Auckland, NZ
Members Ride
2015 VF SV6 Commodore
Oh, so no cause for concern? Just read (few seconds ago) it might be the A/C, but if it's intentional then I'm super happy.

Will upgrade to a V8 one day.
 

426Cuda

SUBLIME!
Joined
Dec 15, 2013
Messages
4,181
Reaction score
3,015
Points
113
Location
Wagga Wagga
Members Ride
VF Redline Sedan - A6 Spitfire MSE...
Oh, so no cause for concern? Just read (few seconds ago) it might be the A/C, but if it's intentional then I'm super happy.

Will upgrade to a V8 one day.
Whoops, scrap that sorry mate. I thought it was a V8. Should've read the title!
Not sure. Could be any number of things irrespective if it's a 6 or 8. Spark issue, e.g plug, lead, coil; fuelling issue eg injector; compression e.g head gasket, or nothing at all. I'm no expert and even if I was, diagnosis via this thread would be difficult at best. More likely, just wrong.
Probs best to have it looked at if you're concerned.
 

crew_man

Active Member
Joined
Jun 16, 2010
Messages
329
Reaction score
56
Points
28
Members Ride
VFII SV6 Reserve Edition Sportwagon
I'm pretty sure that it's normal. It happens to my VFII SV6 which was bought brand new and has 9000km's on it.

I have seen a number of threads pop up asking the same question and from all accounts it seems that it happens to all SV6's
 

diysv6

Active Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2005
Messages
547
Reaction score
28
Points
28
Location
SEQ
Members Ride
VF S1 SV6 STORM A6: VZ S1 SV6 A5
Sorry for the epistle, but it may be helpful.

From experience with my VZ SV6, I found the idle stability was poor when the EVAP solenoid was activated by the ECU. Especially when cold started. The EVAP did not necessarily activate as soon as the engine was started, but started chattering about half a minute after engine start. In colder climates it may start even later?

Normally, the EVAP chatters (closed/open/closed cycles) and using inlet manifold vacuum, pulls pulses of air through the fuel system's carbon canister into the inlet manifold. The air from the canister can be loaded with fuel vapour eg, hot day fuel vapour pressure expansion from the fuel tank, excessive raw fuel after the fuel tank has been overfilled. This extra fuel will richen the fuel air ratio and consequently the O2 sensors will try to correct. I think the chattering of the valve stops a "full on" change to the air fuel mixture, as the inlet manifold chamber will mix or "blend" air drawn through the throttle plate and the EVAP and the crankcase ventilation (CV) metering. The EVAP cycles timing may be such that the O2 sensors don't/cannot chase the A/F mixture changes diligently, and start making large compensatory changes to ignition timing and fuel injection on/off times etc. I think the O2 sensors respond in a more subdued manner and idle speed quality reflects this condition.

Find the line to the EVAP near the inlet manifold, if it can be safely crimped to stop air flow, then evaluate your idle smoothness. In the VZ, it was solid vacuum lines, so I removed the quick connect fittings at the EVAP, and used rubber chair tips, 8mm or 10mm in diameter from memory, to block the air to the inlet manifold. My VZ idle improved to be very steady and the motor did not have any shakes etc. Reconnected the EVAP and idle was not as good.

My VF SV6 S1 cold idle feels a bit unstable but when up to operating temperature the idle is acceptable. When cold started, I put it down to the O2 sensors not being in the loop and the EVAP having a chatter as well. So, unless it gets bad at operating temperature, I presently have to accept the designers' compromises between engine performance and pollution controls.

If bad when hot, then the usual items come into play. Plugs, injectors, ECU, EVAP leaking, vacuum leaks, CV blockages, fuel pump, wiring, earthing, faults etc. etc. Some of these faulty components don't give fault codes.

Hope you can solve your problem.
 

MossNZ

New Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2017
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Points
1
Age
34
Location
Auckland, NZ
Members Ride
2015 VF SV6 Commodore
Sorry for the epistle, but it may be helpful.

From experience with my VZ SV6, I found the idle stability was poor when the EVAP solenoid was activated by the ECU. Especially when cold started. The EVAP did not necessarily activate as soon as the engine was started, but started chattering about half a minute after engine start. In colder climates it may start even later?

Normally, the EVAP chatters (closed/open/closed cycles) and using inlet manifold vacuum, pulls pulses of air through the fuel system's carbon canister into the inlet manifold. The air from the canister can be loaded with fuel vapour eg, hot day fuel vapour pressure expansion from the fuel tank, excessive raw fuel after the fuel tank has been overfilled. This extra fuel will richen the fuel air ratio and consequently the O2 sensors will try to correct. I think the chattering of the valve stops a "full on" change to the air fuel mixture, as the inlet manifold chamber will mix or "blend" air drawn through the throttle plate and the EVAP and the crankcase ventilation (CV) metering. The EVAP cycles timing may be such that the O2 sensors don't/cannot chase the A/F mixture changes diligently, and start making large compensatory changes to ignition timing and fuel injection on/off times etc. I think the O2 sensors respond in a more subdued manner and idle speed quality reflects this condition.

Find the line to the EVAP near the inlet manifold, if it can be safely crimped to stop air flow, then evaluate your idle smoothness. In the VZ, it was solid vacuum lines, so I removed the quick connect fittings at the EVAP, and used rubber chair tips, 8mm or 10mm in diameter from memory, to block the air to the inlet manifold. My VZ idle improved to be very steady and the motor did not have any shakes etc. Reconnected the EVAP and idle was not as good.

My VF SV6 S1 cold idle feels a bit unstable but when up to operating temperature the idle is acceptable. When cold started, I put it down to the O2 sensors not being in the loop and the EVAP having a chatter as well. So, unless it gets bad at operating temperature, I presently have to accept the designers' compromises between engine performance and pollution controls.

If bad when hot, then the usual items come into play. Plugs, injectors, ECU, EVAP leaking, vacuum leaks, CV blockages, fuel pump, wiring, earthing, faults etc. etc. Some of these faulty components don't give fault codes.

Hope you can solve your problem.

Thank you for the detailed explanation of what it could be. Temperatures have been anywhere from 15 - 25 degrees outside when I've started the car and it doesn't feel like much difference between the alternating temps. It's not annoying me, just more concerned. However this qualms any worries I had, there's no affect on actual driveability.
 

treesnake

Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2012
Messages
48
Reaction score
3
Points
8
Location
Perth
Members Ride
VF Sv6 SII Sedan
yeah its like an occasional miss fire, mine does that occasionally when sitting at traffic lights. Not too bothered, although the lumpy throttle the first 30 secs after cold start up is a bit annoying
 

zero_tolerance

Donating Member
Joined
Dec 2, 2015
Messages
737
Reaction score
973
Points
93
Age
43
Location
Melbourne
Members Ride
MY17 VFII Redline
Noticed the car feels like it's jerking to one side when it's sitting idle in gear (at the lights), and in park. It's not constant, but varies. The car was serviced before I took collection of it, and has done 35,560 to the clock.

I'm new to Holden's, did some searching and saw older cars doing it but threads cut short. It drives fine in every other regard.

Sorry for lack of knowledge.

Out of curiosity, what fuel are you using?
My old VE 3.6 sidi was silky smooth and could be barely felt at idle, but then I noticed it suddenly started to have a noticeable lumpy idle.
I put it down to BP Ultimate and the new additives they started using, because once I switched back to regular 91 it instantly became smooth again.
 

MaxCommie689

Donating Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2020
Messages
412
Reaction score
267
Points
63
Location
South-West of Sydney
Members Ride
2016 Calais V
I put it down to BP Ultimate and the new additives they started using, because once I switched back to regular 91 it instantly became smooth again.

Bumping up an old thread here.
I have been noticing a bit of lumpiness at idle - it seems have started after I switched to Shell 98. I'll try switching back to 91 or E10.
 
Top