Demons1964
Member
- Joined
- Feb 2, 2004
- Messages
- 453
- Reaction score
- 15
- Points
- 18
- Age
- 47
- Location
- SE Melbourne
- Members Ride
- VY Calais, WHII Statesman V8, VC L 202
So, shouldn't the question be rephrased "What makes a commodore a commodore?"
If it's the fact that that the engine is made in Australia then there's a big gulf between the VK and the VZ because the Nissan 3L and Buick V6 rule out VL to VY. If its that the engine was designed in Australia, you can almost rule out the VZ (Global V6 was designed globally with input from Australia). For that matter rule out the EFI 202 in the VK because Bosch did the injection. So now you're back to the carby 202 in the VK. But even that has it's origin in old USA GM designs dating back from before the grey motor.
So, what about the V8? Same deal there, modified GM design for the 253 but given enough design room locally for stroking to the 308 then had another local iteration with fuel injection to the 304. Then the North American Gen III and Gen IV came along.
Is it the fact that the car is assembled in Australia? If the VZ was assembled in Brazil for the USA market it would still be a commodore.
From my viewpoint if the majority of the car is designed in Australia for Australian conditions and it's badged a commodore, then it's a commodore.
If it's the fact that that the engine is made in Australia then there's a big gulf between the VK and the VZ because the Nissan 3L and Buick V6 rule out VL to VY. If its that the engine was designed in Australia, you can almost rule out the VZ (Global V6 was designed globally with input from Australia). For that matter rule out the EFI 202 in the VK because Bosch did the injection. So now you're back to the carby 202 in the VK. But even that has it's origin in old USA GM designs dating back from before the grey motor.
So, what about the V8? Same deal there, modified GM design for the 253 but given enough design room locally for stroking to the 308 then had another local iteration with fuel injection to the 304. Then the North American Gen III and Gen IV came along.
Is it the fact that the car is assembled in Australia? If the VZ was assembled in Brazil for the USA market it would still be a commodore.
From my viewpoint if the majority of the car is designed in Australia for Australian conditions and it's badged a commodore, then it's a commodore.