If i had to chose between the two itd always be the Senator... But if I had the money I would be looking at a 08-09 VE SS with all the remainder cash packet into the car in aftermarket stuff. Or if you still want the HSV look, a VY-VZ Senator with the left over cash tucked into some pretty serious mods.. Unfortunately, I am not in ur position.. I did however have a simlar Q a while back.. VY SS or VXII Clubby R8 -> the clubby won and Id do it the same way over and over.. everyone has there preferences, I knew right from the start when i posted the comments that i had my heard set on the clubby, i wanted to know what other ppl thought, but end of the day.. was always gunna be my clubby.. now if it was Senator V Clubby for me.. haha whole different ball game... have fun with that one