- Joined
- Apr 15, 2006
- Messages
- 22,679
- Reaction score
- 20,681
- Points
- 113
- Location
- Sth Auck, NZ
- Members Ride
- HSV VS Senator, VX Calais II L67
That is true but glycol also reduces the efficiency of the coolant to transfer heat so you win a little by increasing the boiling point a couple of degrees but loose efficiency and the engine should never operate at such a high temperature.
The increase in cooling system pressure provides most of the increase in boiling point.
But great marketing makes people believe you must run anti-freeze in hot climates when it simply isn't required.
So your V6 runs at 20psi which means with plain water the boiling point of the cooling system is 260°F or 126°C. If your engine gets this hot there are some serious problems. If you run anit-freeze (at 50%) that increases to 135°C or 7% over straight water, yippy but at those temps you've probably fucked the motor regardless so I wouldn't be going there.
Here is some interesting reading about the effects of glycol in cooling systems, it's quite intensive reading.
But to quote from the above page,
Now back in the linked page above at 80°C - 100°C at 50% glycol the specific heat is about .88 or 12% less efficient than straight water and it gets worse as the %age of glycol increases.
Glycol based coolants are expensive, do you really need it? TBH, I don't care, it's not my money but don't believe all the marketing hype about anti-freeze. What you do need is corrosive inhibitors.
edit: add context
Holden fitted a 195°F/91°C thermostat to your 3.8 V6 motor (I take this to mean that this is the engine temp Holden wants the motor to operate), Holden set the low speed thermofan to turn on at 104°C and the high speed thermofan at 109°C, this tells me Holden doesn't really want the engine to get above this temp and still a fair margin to 126°C before you reach the boiling point.
The increase in cooling system pressure provides most of the increase in boiling point.
But great marketing makes people believe you must run anti-freeze in hot climates when it simply isn't required.
So your V6 runs at 20psi which means with plain water the boiling point of the cooling system is 260°F or 126°C. If your engine gets this hot there are some serious problems. If you run anit-freeze (at 50%) that increases to 135°C or 7% over straight water, yippy but at those temps you've probably fucked the motor regardless so I wouldn't be going there.
Here is some interesting reading about the effects of glycol in cooling systems, it's quite intensive reading.
Ethylene Glycol Heat-Transfer Fluid Properties
Properties like freezing point, viscosity, specific gravity and specific heat of ethylene glycol based heat-transfer fluids, or brines.
www.engineeringtoolbox.com
But to quote from the above page,
Note! The specific heat of ethylene glycol based water solutions are less than the specific heat of clean water. For a heat transfer system with ethylene glycol the circulated volume must be increased compared to a system only with water.
In a 50% solution with operational temperatures above 36 oF the specific heat capacity is decreased with approximately 20%. The reduced heat capacity must be compensated by circulating more fluid.
Note! The density of ethylene glycol is higher than water - check the specific gravity (SG) table above, so the net impact on the heat transport capacity is reduced. Example - the specific heat of an ethylene glycol water solution 50% / 50% is 0.815 at 80 oF (26.7 oC). Specific gravity at the same conditions is 1.077. The net impact can be estimated to 0.815 * 1.077 = 0.877.
Now back in the linked page above at 80°C - 100°C at 50% glycol the specific heat is about .88 or 12% less efficient than straight water and it gets worse as the %age of glycol increases.
Glycol based coolants are expensive, do you really need it? TBH, I don't care, it's not my money but don't believe all the marketing hype about anti-freeze. What you do need is corrosive inhibitors.
edit: add context
Holden fitted a 195°F/91°C thermostat to your 3.8 V6 motor (I take this to mean that this is the engine temp Holden wants the motor to operate), Holden set the low speed thermofan to turn on at 104°C and the high speed thermofan at 109°C, this tells me Holden doesn't really want the engine to get above this temp and still a fair margin to 126°C before you reach the boiling point.
Last edited: