I've seen a brand new bumper (not sure if original or aftermarket brand) for $160, I think getting one from the wreaker might be cheaper, and painted (assuming your cars white, common).
I have seen quite a few VR/VS front and rear bumpers come up really cheap around here lately. like <$5 a set. Just keep your ear to the ground and you should be able to pick some up pretty cheap. Shipping isnt fun tho.