Welcome to Just Commodores, a site specifically designed for all people who share the same passion as yourself.

New Posts Contact us

Just Commodores Forum Community

It takes just a moment to join our fantastic community

Register

V6 versus straight 6

1991_Vn2nV

New Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2006
Messages
8,718
Reaction score
71
Points
0
Age
36
Location
Gumeracha, Adelaide Hills
Members Ride
91 VN Berlina & 03 VY Berlina
Well a boxer engine has a very very low centre of gravity...but it also runs incredibly smooth and free of vibrations. They are naturally and perfectly balanced as well because the movement of each piston is counteracted by the piston opposite it. The boxer engines are able to rev higher due to a lightweight crankshaft and natural balancing.... which equals more power.
 

grigor

New Member
Joined
Jan 20, 2006
Messages
78
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Members Ride
VS Executive, R31, R33
Vee V's in line

It's obviously far more complicated than in line v's vee or even flat.
Every engine has a natural harmonic frequency and most designers gear the engine to run in it's smoothest area, away from harmonics. You'll notice a straight 6 is really happy at around 3000, an inline 4 at about 4500.
The Vee angle is also critical, no use having a 90degree V and 6 cylinders and this is the reason for the Buick's balance shaft. Also the reason GM dreamed up that horrible offset big end crank in the Ecotecs, cheaper than making new blocks with a 60 degree Vee, and of course they knew the 60 degree Alloytec was around the corner.
It all comes down to cost. The V6 is just so much cheaper than an equivalent power in line. Compare the crank, mains etc of an Ecotec to an Rb30. The Rb has 7 mains and a massive main bearing cradle, built like a truck and also found in the 1JZ. The Ecotec has 4-side drilled mains and gets additional help from the alloy sump.
As for V12's they suffer from exactly the same frequency problems as any other engine. GM's 4000hp loco engines were continually snapping cranks until they made a different firing order crank to shift the harmonics out of the operating RPM.
Apparently 5-cylinders is smooth as.
 

ascension24

New Member
Joined
Dec 6, 2005
Messages
210
Reaction score
1
Points
0
Age
37
"As for V12's they suffer from exactly the same frequency problems as any other engine."

Im sure if you do some research, youll find that a V12 is an extremely smooth configuration, more so then any other engine configuration. (of the standard types)

Have driven a porsche boxster, and have to say it was like the engine wasnt even running, very very nice.

Harmonics really depend on the materials used, as every materal has a different resonate frequency.

But a car company is going to use what they have, their not going to reinvent the wheel, when they have a perfectly good engine going on.
 
Top